Close up shot of cheesecake slice with cherry drizzle on a round plate next to gold fork.

Smoked Whiskey Old Fashioned Cheesecake

Inspired
Serving Time Icon 13 HR 40 MIN
Serves Number Icon Yields 1 8-inch Cake

Radical Gardens draws people from across their region for their food and their creative desserts and cakes. For those of us who live far away from their Timmins location, we can now enjoy this incredible cheesecake at home.

 

Cheesecakes are incredibly versatile desserts and can be made with sweet or savoury flavour profiles. In our opinion, the best cheesecakes offer a layered flavour experience, introducing new, complementary flavours in every bite. Brianna and Steve from Radical Gardens recommend smoking this cheesecake as a finishing touch. “We’re really enjoying mesquite, but feel free to use what you have available!”

 

Ontario cream cheese is readily available in grocery stores and is the perfect base for a whiskey flavour infusion. Ontario small-batch distillers now offer a wide range of whiskies to bring this cheesecake to life!

Pairing

Enjoy this dish with 2018 Riesling, Tawse Winery (VQA Vinemount Ridge)!

VQA Ontario wine pairing courtesy of the Ontario Wine Marketing Association
 

Live in Timmins, Ontario?

Try another delicious dish from Radical Gardens like their unreal Duck Perogies for a limited time! Click here for their menu.

Prep 25 MIN

Cook 1 HR 15 MIN

Chill 12 HR

*Chef’s note: You will need a water bath to make the cheesecake.

Cheesecake

Whiskey Chocolate Buttercream

Method

Step 1

Make the cheesecake…

Preheat oven to 350°F (177°C).
 

Step 2

In a small pan, melt butter and combine with cookie crumbs; press into 8-inch springform pan and bake in oven until solid and toasted. Let cool.
 

Step 3

Preheat oven to 450°F (232°C). Using a stand mixer with a paddle attachment, mix cream cheese and sugar until nicely creamed and fluffy, scraping the sides of the bowl and paddle  multiple times while creaming. Makesure to get all lumps.
 

Step 4

Add heavy cream, vanilla and flour and continue to cream together. Add eggs, one at a time, until all eggs are incorporated, making sure not to overbeat.
 

Step 5

Separate the cheesecake filling into two bowls. Add cherries to one and orange zest to the other with 1 tbsp of whiskey per bowl. GENTLY fold everything together in their separate bowls. Do not overmix.
 

Step 6

Pour the contents of the bowl with cherry filling straight into the springform pan, then spoon in the orange zest mixture in random dollops into the same springform pan. Use a butter knife to gently swirl them together.
 

Step 7

Wrap the springform pan in tin foil so your water bath doesn’t leak in.
 

Step 8

Make a waterbath by heating water in a kettle to add to a large (must be large enough to fit your springform pan), ovensafe baking dish. Set the foil-wrapped cheesecake inside, then slowly pour in heated water from the kettle, taking care not to splash water in your cake mixture.
 

Step 9

Place in oven and bake for 15 minutes, then turn oven down to 225°F (107°C) to bake about 60 minutes more or until the centre of the cheesecake is jiggly but set and springs back when you push it slightly.
 

Step 10

Let cool 1 hour, then refrigerate overnight.
 

Chef’s tip: Smoke the cheesecake (optional, but delicious)…

Set up your smoker (preferably a cold smoker) OR use a handheld smoker and a dome. Smoke cheesecake for about 5-10 minutes.

 

Step 11

Make the cherry topping…

Combine cherries, lemon juice, zest, and sugar in saucepan and cook at medium heat.
 

Step 12

Combine water and cornstarch in a cup and whisk until combined, then add to saucepan.
 

Step 13

Let thicken for about 6-8 min on medium, then remove from heat and let cool; set aside. Reserve ¾ cup for your cheesecake and use the rest to make some pies!
 

Step 14

Finish the cheesecake…

Drizzle cherry topping over cheesecake and serve.

 

Step 15

Level it up with a dollop of whiskey chocolate buttercream and a maraschino cherry.

Brianna and Steve from Radical Gardens
Written By

Brianna Humphrey and Steve McIntosh

Chef Duo & Owners of Radical Gardens

See More Recipes

Apple Crumble Tarts on a round green plate with Maple-Whipped Ontario Cream in the centre.

Apple Crumble Tarts with Maple-Whipped Ontario Cream

Inspired
 Clock Icon 45 min
Baked Double Cream Brie with Nuts, Cranberries, Caramelized Honey & Thyme in a small cast iron pan on a blue napkin.

Baked Ontario Double Cream Brie with Nuts, Cranberries, Caramelized Honey & Thyme

Inspired
 Clock Icon 30 min
Charred Leek & Mountainoak Gouda Risotto in a round black dish next to a glass of white wine.

Charred Leek & Farmstead GOLD Gouda Risotto

Inspired
 Clock Icon 40 min
Overhead view of Comfort Creamed Onions in a oval black serving dish on top of a red and white patterned napkin next to a small wooden serving board with brie cheese next to a knife, a plate of bread slices, a plate of bread slices with comfort creamed onions topped with brie cheese and a glass of red wine.

Comfort Creamed Onions

Inspired
 Clock Icon 4 hr 10 min
Double Scalloped Potatoes with Aged Ontario Gouda in a round, black cast iron dish with handles topped with fresh sage leaves.

Double Scalloped Potatoes with Aged Ontario Gouda

Inspired
 Clock Icon 2 Hr 10 min
Overhead view of a white round baking dish with creamed Ontario corn next to a wooden serving board of cheese and a glass of red wine

Harvest Creamed Ontario Corn with Handeck Cheese, Hazelnuts, & Cherry Tomatoes

Inspired
 Clock Icon 2 hr 20 min
Apple Crumble Tarts on a round green plate with Maple-Whipped Ontario Cream in the centre.

Apple Crumble Tarts with Maple-Whipped Ontario Cream

Inspired
 Clock Icon 45 min
Baked Double Cream Brie with Nuts, Cranberries, Caramelized Honey & Thyme in a small cast iron pan on a blue napkin.

Baked Ontario Double Cream Brie with Nuts, Cranberries, Caramelized Honey & Thyme

Inspired
 Clock Icon 30 min
Charred Leek & Mountainoak Gouda Risotto in a round black dish next to a glass of white wine.

Charred Leek & Farmstead GOLD Gouda Risotto

Inspired
 Clock Icon 40 min
Overhead view of Comfort Creamed Onions in a oval black serving dish on top of a red and white patterned napkin next to a small wooden serving board with brie cheese next to a knife, a plate of bread slices, a plate of bread slices with comfort creamed onions topped with brie cheese and a glass of red wine.

Comfort Creamed Onions

Inspired
 Clock Icon 4 hr 10 min
Double Scalloped Potatoes with Aged Ontario Gouda in a round, black cast iron dish with handles topped with fresh sage leaves.

Double Scalloped Potatoes with Aged Ontario Gouda

Inspired
 Clock Icon 2 Hr 10 min
Overhead view of a white round baking dish with creamed Ontario corn next to a wooden serving board of cheese and a glass of red wine

Harvest Creamed Ontario Corn with Handeck Cheese, Hazelnuts, & Cherry Tomatoes

Inspired
 Clock Icon 2 hr 20 min
A large smoked turkey on a serving platter next to a small pitcher of gravy.

Herb & Wine Smoked Turkey with Henry’s Gravy

Inspired
 Clock Icon 5 hr 55 min
Overhead view of Burrata & Stone Fruit Flambé on a white round plate with some gold cutlery.

Ontario Burrata & Stone Fruit Flambé

Inspired
 Clock Icon 15 min

Pelham's Famous Thanksgiving Dressing

Inspired
 Clock Icon 1 hr 30 min

Sheldon Creek's Farmhouse Cauliflower Soup

Inspired
 Clock Icon 50 min
Overhead view of Waldorf Salad in a round bowl next to a plate of cheese and a glass of of red wine.

Waldorf Salad with Ontario Blue Cheese

Inspired
 Clock Icon 35 min
Three steak wraps in a round orange dish on top of a white napkin next to a bowl of veggies, cream cheese dip, cilantro, and a plate of flour tortillas.

Japanese Garlic Sesame Cream Cheese Steak Wrap

Quick & Easy
 Clock Icon 45 min
A large smoked turkey on a serving platter next to a small pitcher of gravy.

Herb & Wine Smoked Turkey with Henry’s Gravy

Inspired
 Clock Icon 5 hr 55 min
Overhead view of Burrata & Stone Fruit Flambé on a white round plate with some gold cutlery.

Ontario Burrata & Stone Fruit Flambé

Inspired
 Clock Icon 15 min

Pelham's Famous Thanksgiving Dressing

Inspired
 Clock Icon 1 hr 30 min

Sheldon Creek's Farmhouse Cauliflower Soup

Inspired
 Clock Icon 50 min
Overhead view of Waldorf Salad in a round bowl next to a plate of cheese and a glass of of red wine.

Waldorf Salad with Ontario Blue Cheese

Inspired
 Clock Icon 35 min
Three steak wraps in a round orange dish on top of a white napkin next to a bowl of veggies, cream cheese dip, cilantro, and a plate of flour tortillas.

Japanese Garlic Sesame Cream Cheese Steak Wrap

Quick & Easy
 Clock Icon 45 min

See More...